Accuracy
~1ΔE
That's the average difference from a film pack's own profiles for the same cameras, across 40,000 colours.
How it works
Every camera profile is a recipe Lightroom runs in a fixed order. The first two steps cancel out the quirks of one sensor. The last two are the style.
the cameraMatricesCalibration
the lookLook tableTone curve
Look makers don't build each camera's profile from scratch. They start from Adobe Standard for that camera, which Adobe has tuned since 2008 so every camera's colour roughly agrees, and add their style on top. So if you have a look's profile for one camera and Adobe Standard for the same camera, the difference between them is the look itself, with the camera taken out. Extra Sauce works that difference out for every colour: it undoes Adobe Standard's calibration, then applies the look's own calibration and look table. It then fine-tunes the result against the original profile's actual output across 200,000 colours, which roughly halves what's left of the difference.
look = LookTable ∘ HueSatMap ∘ (Adobe Standard HueSatMap)⁻¹
To build the profile for your new camera, it starts from that camera's own Adobe Standard profile, whose matrices and calibration already handle the new sensor. It swaps in the extracted look, sampled across 90 hues, 25 saturations and 16 brightness levels, and copies across the original tone curve. The new file keeps the original profile name, so a preset that asks for that profile finds a version made for the new body.
It works inside the profile rather than as a filter on the finished image because by then the most saturated colours are already clipped, and no filter afterwards can bring them back. Inside the profile, the look sees the same colour data the original maker's did.
Each conversion checks itself by rebuilding the look for the camera it came from and comparing that with the real profile across 40,000 colours. If one look scores noticeably worse, try a different source camera: Adobe has revised some cameras' Adobe Standard profiles over the years.